Hi,
as stated on the reference documentation in paragraph
4.2.1. Built-in bridges, all Dates are converted and indexed using GMT timezone.
This is strongly recommended for all servers, it really simplifies a lot of Date-math operations; you should covert to a different timezone on the presentation layer only.
BTW I might be wrong, but I think that GMT-5 is not the same as America/New_York, at least not at all moments of the year, as each state applies daylight shifts/legal hours at dates they decide themselves; another good reason to avoid using localized times on the server side.