Hi,

I hope this is the right place for this question. I am currently working on a project and we are moving to the next stage of development. This involves upgrading the frameworks and tools that we are using and as such, we upgraded Hibernate to version 3.0.5.

We now have an issue that was resolved in hibernate 3.1.beta 1. The issue was: HHH-577, "joins within subqueries on dbs supporting ansi-joins result in extraneous commas".

I see that this was not fixed in 3.0 and would like to know if and when it will be? If this question cannot be answered, when is it *likely* that Hibernate 3.1 will be production ready so that we dont scare management too much?

Thanks,

Brendan

As always, we release stuff when it is ready, not to meet arbitrary deadlines ;-)

I would *like* to see a 3.1 release candidate in time for JBoss World, but this is Steve's call and since he was working on Seam all weekend with no sleep, I think we'd better give him the chance to take it easy for a few days.

FWIW, that is my goal also. That being said, I am traveling most of this week and wont get much time for development.

Really, to me, this is just another indication of a deeper issue. I am really not liking the way we keep from-element and join infomation in the hql-sql AST. The current way makes it very difficult to manage that subtree during sql rendering, which is the underlying cause of many of these issues regarding comma generation.

But honestly, I am not so certain that could be put in place in a 3.1 timeframe. It may be best to just put out these little fires for 3.1 (at least for rc1).

The issue you mention was fixed as it relates to that user's supplied test case. Submit a *simplified* test case reproducing what you see to JIRA and I'll have a look.